| Entire Mars Mission |
✘ Scope way too broad |
| Phased Mars exploration mission |
Challenge: Establishment of multiplanetary species
No defined scientific or technological uncertainty
|
Approach: Phased interplanetary mission strategies
No planned steps for experiments or investigation
|
|
✘ Not linked to core |
✘ Not linked to core |
$500M / $0 |
| Expenditure not traceable |
| Apportionment not meaningful |
| No claim |
|
| Exploration System Development |
~ Significant apportionment required |
|
Develop Mars exploration systems and operational protocols
|
Challenge: System performance and mission readiness under Mars conditions
Mixed technical and operational uncertainties
|
Approach: High-level planning supported by validation testing
Systematic investigative approach only for parts
|
|
~ Partial (high-level planning) |
✘ Not linked to core |
$50M / $3M |
| Some parts traceable |
| Apportionment required |
| Slower process, bad surprises at SR time |
|
| Turbopump Design |
✔ Clearly eligible core R&D |
|
Design, build and test turbopump systems
|
Challenge: Understand and optimise flow, thermal and structural limits across design variants
Scientific or technological uncertainty OK
|
Approach: Comparative evaluation via simulation and physical experimentation
Systematic planned steps to experiment and investigate
|
|
✔ Directly linked to core |
✔ Directly linked to core |
$4M / $4M |
| All cost traceable to R&D |
| No apportionment needed |
| Full claim |
|
| Turbopump Bearing Testing |
~ Eligible but limited claim |
|
Test turbopump bearings under variable thermal loads
|
Challenge: Understand vibration response and fatigue performance
Technological uncertainty OK
|
Approach: Instrumented testing using accelerometers and strain gauges
Systematic planned approach to experiment
|
|
~ Partial (micro-test planning) |
~ Partial (bearing-specific CFD) |
$0.5M / $0.5M |
| Traceable if activity documented |
| No apportionment if cost tracked |
| Higher admin, lower claim |
|
| Component Cleaning |
✘ Operational routine activity |
|
Ultrasonic solvent cleaning of test fixtures and components
|
Challenge: Maintaining contamination-free test conditions
Operational requirement, not a technological uncertainty
|
Approach: Established ultrasonic cleaning processes
Standard practice; no experimentation or investigation
|
|
✘ Not linked to core |
✘ Not linked to core |
$0.05M / $0 |
| No link to R&D activities |
| Operational expenditure only |
| Routine task, no claim |
|